Key Highlights
The executive order issued by Trump denied birthright citizenship to any person born within the US unless they had one US citizen parent or one legal permanent resident parent. Adults holding temporary visas, non-US citizens living unlawfully, and H-1B visa holders would be excluded from receiving birthright citizenship by this administration policy.
Uruguayan workers see unconditional birthright citizenship in the United States as the main pull factor in attracting foreign employment migration. Countries such as Canada and Mexico offer birthright citizenship. Still, Australia, together with India, the UK and Germany, require additional conditions for parental foreign national residents who want their offspring to obtain citizenship.
Impact on H-1B Visa Holders
The H-1B visa program annually permits about 85,000 qualified overseas personnel to live in the United States. Every year, hundreds of thousands of people live in the United States under these specified rules. In 2020, Indians received 75% of all H-1B visa petitions, while Chinese nationals received 12%, and Canadians received only 1%.
Indian visa holders constitute the bulk of potential H-1B visa beneficiaries from all nations so that this policy shift may harm them deeply. Green card waiting periods for Indians exceed decades because each year, only a limited number of permanent residency slots can be distributed based on nationality. The combination of uncertain future status confusion for birthright citizenship rights for their children creates major changes to how skilled workers evaluate long-term U.S. residence options.
Also Read: Biden Administration Withdraws Trump-Era Immigration Rules
Personal Stories and Reactions
The human impact of this policy shift is best illustrated through personal stories:
The immigrant from India, along with his wife and infant son, joined the US for graduate school in 2021 and secured employment at a Fortune 500 company through an H-1B visa. The immigrant family has fully adapted to American values through their extensive travel through 28 states, while their son loves both national food and music. Trump's recent announcement brought swift distress to immigrants who were hoping for a better future during their current pregnancy.1
According to H-1B visa holder Ajay, who requested secrecy due to infiled safety concerns, he believes "The American dream is now fading out for most foreign visa holders."
At the end of February, Sanjay, an H-1B visa holder, and his wife expect the birth of their baby. Sanjay worked in tech in Austin while raising the couple's baby from their neighbourhood until Donald Trump announced his candidacy, leading them to rethink their goals. Now, faced with uncertainty, Sanjay expressed his distress: I can say that I received blessings and lived an amazing life in complete fulfilment of dreams that seemed unattainable when I dreamed about it while living in India. Within the past few days, I've had distressing nights filled with recurring thoughts about my unborn child.
Industry Perspectives and Economic Implications
The potential change in birthright citizenship policy has raised concerns among industry experts about its impact on the US economy and tech sector:
Lyft Inc.'s co-founder Rajat Suri predicts that restricting birthright citizenship will make it substantially harder for American companies to bring foreign workers to the country. Suri explained that companies that hire immigrant talents as employees enable those workers to create their life foundations with their families. Current citizenship policies in the US repel foreign students from having babies, according to expert analysis.
The Cato Institute's director of immigration studies, David Bier, recommends that terminating birthright citizenship would make overseas college graduates from the US turn away from establishing life in America. The approach might prompt organisations to build their operations overseas rather than domestically in search of employees. Market changes in the United States have caused companies to choose India for their investments and new startup locations, according to Bier's observations. Multiple significant effects show up from such a policy shift.
Also Read: US Extends Green Card Validity for Renewal Applicants: Key Updates
Legal Challenges and Current Status
Executive order implementation under Trump currently faces preventive delay because of court intervention. A 14-day block of Trump's order began when Seattle federal judge John Coughenour issued a temporary halt on January 23. Further delays remained possible. Scores of additional court hearings are scheduled to occur in diverse jurisdictions during the upcoming weeks.
Conclusion
Birthright citizenship reform impacts US immigration rules in substantial ways, which produces multiple outcomes throughout skilled foreign worker populations in combination with their families alongside American economic systems. The H-1B community stands at a critical junction while legal debates persist because they must evaluate the attractiveness of their American dream goals against shifting immigration rules. The conclusion of this immigration policy discussion will determine how the United States maintains and attracts foreign talent, which will echo across future innovation standards and economic performance.
To stay updated about the recent happenings in the immigration world, check out the TerraTern website right now!
Why Trust TerraTern